Cranes collapsed as storm raged: are new regs needed?
On behalf of Carl Lustig of Arye, Lustig & Sassower, P.C. posted in Construction Accidents on Tuesday, November 7, 2017.
Images of raging winds and torrential rain filled the news in recent days as we in New York City watched Hurricane Irma pummel Florida. One of the videos that made an especially strong impression was from Miami, where a construction crane spun out of control atop a high-rise.
News reports indicated that two cranes collapsed in Miami, sending debris onto the empty streets below. A crane in nearby Fort Lauderdale also reportedly collapsed during the ferocious storm. For those in the construction industry, the reports were reminders of the several deadly New York City crane collapses in recent years.
In South Florida, developers and contractors rushed to say the cranes had been secured, though the collapses provide evidence aplenty that whatever had been done before the storm was not enough. Fortunately, no one was injured in the collapses that took place during Irma's rage.
Enforcing critical safety rules According to Miami's city attorney, Florida law prevents cities from enforcing regulations on cranes. So the city simply enforces federal statutes. Our readers will undoubtedly recall that New York City tightened regulations after last year's Manhattan crane collapse in which one person was killed and three others injured. In the TriBeCa tragedy, a 565-foot crawler crane crashed across two city blocks.
But developers and contractors in Florida are dismissing all calls for stricter safety regulations there. A Miami newspaper quoted one developer who said, "we have no evidence that the cranes failed to meet their expected wind capacity." Many people would point to the collapsed cranes as all the evidence needed.
Workers and bystanders injured in New York City construction site accidents have the right to pursue compensation for all damages with the help of a qualified attorney.
Since 1965, we’ve recovered over $1 BILLION on behalf of our clients. read more
$2.1 million settlement
for 33-year old electrician who fell from ladder while attempting to fit heavy cable into crown box when cable sprung back and struck him, causing him to suffer left shoulder injury with impingement.
$1.6 million settlement
for 38-year old electrician who slipped and fell on debris on stairway with resulting cervical herniated disc and aggravation of pre-existing arthritic changes.
$2.55 million settlement
for 42-year old electrician who fell into an uncovered, unprotected hole and suffered a severe low back injury with herniated disc(s) that required surgery at L4-5 and L5-S1 levels.
$1.75 million settlement
for 26-year old construction worker who fell through opening in roof and fractured his wrist, requiring surgery with open reduction and internal fixation, external fixation device, and eventual fusion.
$2.5 million settlement
for 38-year old female electrician (with history of prior neck injury) who tripped on uneven Masonite protective floor covering, and suffered neck injury with herniated discs requiring cervical fusion.
$1.2 million settlement
during trial for 40-year old sheet metal worker who was struck in the neck and shoulder by an air conditioning unit and suffered herniated cervical discs and cervical radiculopathy.
*AV Preeminent is the highest rating of Reed Elsevier Properties Inc., used in accordance with the Martindale-Hubbell certification procedures, standards and policies. Martindale-Hubbell is the facilitator of a peer review rating process. Ratings reflect the confidential opinions of members of the Bar and the judiciary. Martindale-Hubbell ratings fall into two categories - legal ability and general ethical standards.
New York’s Premier Construction Accident And Personal Injury Lawyers